Even less accurate fuel gauge sender

Discussion in 'Mech Tech' started by mikedjames, Jan 16, 2022.

  1. mikedjames

    mikedjames Supporter

    I bought a fuel gauge sender recently to replace one where the resistance track disintegrated cut through by the movement of the wiper arm after about 90000 miles.
    This new one has a linear wound resistor the wire is just wrapped round the former , while the old one had three different pitches of winding the resistance wire round the former.

    The old sender was pretty bad, started at 3/4 full for a full tank, but for all the time there was fuel in the tank, it still read something, despite dropping to the red zone after 100 miles, but then staying in the red zone for 100 miles, going 3 "steps" below zero after about 220 miles.

    The new JPM brand sender starts at 3/4 full as before but with the linear winding, the gauge drops pretty smoothly to zero at about 100 miles then vanishes off towards empty ... Which is annoying when the bus does about 220 miles on a tank of fuel.

    Anybody else seen this problem ?
     
  2. theBusmonkey

    theBusmonkey Sponsor

    Yep. On JP branded syncro senders. Another instance of a nearly but not quite copy from Denmark. They fill a hole...
     
  3. Faust

    Faust Supporter

    All very complicated Mike ...if it wasn't for the bends in the filler neck a long thin piece of wood would give comfort and reasonable accuracy .
     
    EggBoxes, redgaz, Meltman and 4 others like this.
  4. theBusmonkey

    theBusmonkey Sponsor

    Got one of them for the boat tank...:D:D:thumbsup:
     
    Zed and Faust like this.
  5. Faust

    Faust Supporter

    Is it diesel ...always shows better on wood than petrol .
     
  6. theBusmonkey

    theBusmonkey Sponsor

    Red ;)
     
    Faust and Mattlad like this.
  7. Not a new sender on our bus but it shows over full when full dramatically dropping over 100miles to under zero then your on your own guess work.

    the T3 shows over full when full unless you fill up at some filling stations where you can’t get enough in to fill the tank up fully for some bizarre reason. Then alarmingly drops to somewhere in the red zone where you can get anything from 80 quids worth in to brim it or sometimes it’s only £40 it makes no sense - probably due to atmospheric pressures -

    I don’t think these fuel gauge things will catch on….
     
    Lasty likes this.
  8. I've often wondered if a linear potentiometer, like you would have as a volume or tone pot on a electric guitar, wired across the fuel guage would work, if you turned the pot to find the fuel gauge full and empty point then connect the float arm to work between those two points !!! Might be worth experimenting with !!
     
  9. Norris

    Norris Supporter

    Upper and lower range trim pots?
     
  10. That might work but a trimpot is usually set to a value whereas a pot is more used for variable value that's being changed constantly
     
  11. Zed

    Zed Gradually getting grumpier

    The originals were wrapped around a shaped former to account for the paddle arc and the wires were equi-distant throughout and close together making a smoother surface that didn't wear out so quickly. :)
    Cheap and cheerful now. :(
     
    snotty, mikedjames and matty like this.
  12. mikedjames

    mikedjames Supporter

    I use a fibreglass top sail batten on my boat to measure diesel depth, I used to use bamboo or wooden dowels until I lost the end of the stick a few times .. And I gave up on bothering with red diesel years back. It doesnt use enough to bother with the different price .

    To be honest, the best fuel gauge I have come across was a pressure sensor at the bottom of the fuel tank, and a software tool that you put in the profile of the tank. The pressure is proportional to the depth , the fuel left is
    the integral of the cross section areas of the tank. I have also come across one that used an ultrasonic distance measuring system to measure the distance to the top of the fuel, but on that one, having a single cylinder diesel generator hammering away caused so much vibration, the distance measuring went haywire.
     
    Last edited: Jan 17, 2022
    Faust likes this.
  13. Faust

    Faust Supporter

    Red diesel is to be no more soon i believe . Diesel as altered in viscosity over the years .
    The old Derv as was called in 60's was thicker . Old diesel fuel pumps on wagons needed the thicker diesel to lubricate the internals ,they can wear out quicker so i was told with the newer diesel .
    On my old Foden the mini crankshaft on the CAV inline pump had oil fed lube but the barrels and plungers benefited from the old thicker fuel .
     
  14. PIE

    PIE

    I spoke to some guys from VDO at a show, they said that if there became a need for them they would produce a sender and matching gauge with no need for the vibrator. About time we all started emailing them.
     
    PanZer likes this.
  15. Faust

    Faust Supporter

    And the fuel gauge on the tank was all mechanical just a simple dial no electrics ...you just had to get out your cab and have a butchers .
    And if the gauge didn't work just open the filler and look down with a torch or stick .
     
  16. The Beetle fuel gauges are all mechanical, certainly they are before '68, not certain precisely of the exact date, anyway just a float and a Bowden cable to the gauge in the cab, much less to go wrong. Prior to that it was a reserve lever and that was your lot.

    Owning both vehicles shows how much thought Ferdinand and co put into the Beetle's design and how many odd design decisions, by comparison, there are in the Bay.
     
    Zed likes this.
  17. mikedjames

    mikedjames Supporter

    The differences between the prototype and the Late Bay are partly driven by cost down.

    So a quality moving coil gauge was replaced with a spring loaded resistance wire with a lever to multiply the movement. A long variable resistor in the tank was replaced by levers and a smaller resistor track .. and so on ..
     
  18. Does the cross-over have the old style, Mike? I thought it did, one of the transition year quirks.
     
  19. I think you mean a bimetallic strip ;)
     
  20. This is my old one off a 79. It's shaped with a waist in the middle but the wiring also varies in spacing. I had considered getting some nichrome wire and redoing it. It's got notches to guide the wire spacing, but even so my eyesight's not that good. Only about 40 turns though.
    upload_2022-1-17_17-46-43.jpeg
     
    DubCat, Zed and F_Pantos like this.

Share This Page